Auckland Council has, as planned, released its public consultation material for congestion pricing (time of use charging in New Zealand parlance) for Auckland. There are no great surprises here for those of us who have followed this closely, but what will be of interest is the response from the public. There are three proposals being consulted on, but of course some will be proposing that it not be implemented at all.
People have under 11 December 2026 to provide feedback.
There is a lot of material to look at, and I urge those interested to download all they can through the link above.
The timing is deliberate, because it follows just beyond the New Zealand general election which was held on 7 November 2026. The result of that election isn’t certain yet because it is very close, and the counting of special votes (early votes, votes from overseas) will not be concluded until 27 November, which could change it. One thing is almost certain though, even if the centre-right National Party led coalition government is re-elected, there will be a new Minister of Transport, because the existing Minister of Transport, the Hon. Chris Bishop, lost his electorate on election night by a margin that is almost impossible to overturn on special votes. He was instrumental in advancing the policy of congestion pricing, and the role of Minister remains critical, because ultimately the Minister signs off on approving the whole proposal. Who that will be won't be known for at least a couple of weeks.
 |
| Auckland congestion pricing timeline |
So after this, Council will vote on a preferred option (if any) by March 2027. At that point the proposal goes to a NZ Transport Agency (central government) chaired Scheme Board, which will work jointly with Auckland Council on developing detailed plans for the preferred option. The Scheme Board will then consult on the detailed option with the public, and Council will be asked to vote on ratifying whether to submit the proposal to the Minister for final approval in 2028. If agreed, the Minister will decided whether or not to approve implementation, which will then follow in around 2030-2031. By then, there will have been another round of Council elections (the last ones were in 2025, next in 2028) and at least one General Election (2029).
I am of two minds about this process. On the one hand, it risks losing momentum and seems to be a very very long time frame to conclude something that should really just have two levels of approval - Council and the Minister. Elsewhere, drawn out processes have seen opposition build and build over time.
On the other hand, it should exhaust people's opposition to the idea, and help ensure that what follows actually gets implemented. If it can survive two more Council votes and a Minister, it should proceed. However, it is probably around 18 months before final approval may be granted.
What is proposed?
First, all you really need to know is:
- All options include a cordon, one includes corridor charges as well;
- Charges are proposed only at AM and PM peaks on weekdays;
- Charges are proposed only in the peak direction of flow (which is sound, except for one corridor which has high flows in both directions);
- Vehicles will be identified using Automatic Number Plate Recognition (ANPR) technology;
- Charges will be subject to multipliers based on vehicle size. Motorcycles at half the car rate, trucks at up to four times (although the Regulations governing this have not been finalised).
The options are focused on the city centre and surrounding corridors. The following images come from the consultation document and explain some of the key comparisons.
 |
Auckland Option A - City Centre cordon
 | | Auckland Option B - City fringe cordon |
|
 |
| Auckland Option C - Core motorway and either A or B |
As you can see, with all options, most peak period motorists pay nothing, because they aren't driving into the cordon or along the charged corridors. The figures for impacts are not dramatic, but they are worthwhile improvements in travel times and trip reliability.
Some of the supplementary material is interesting as well.
 |
| Auckland proposed impact of congestion pricing |
Even the most significant option (C) sees 92% of trips in the morning peak uncharged. Still there is a 4.8% increase in average vehicle trip speeds across the region. The number of vehicle kilometres driven under congested conditions reduces by 11% across the region. 28% for the isthmus and lower North Shore.
Charge 8% of trips, reduce travel time on average across the region.
It's a huge plus that so much of the material focuses on travel time savings, as this is exactly what this is designed to address.
 |
| Main corridor travel times - Auckland congestion pricing |
What could be done better?
There has clearly been some useful modelling done to demonstrate what the three options can do, for those who pay and for those who won't pay, but will benefit. This is critical stuff. However, there are some gaps and I think a missed opportunity to be broader minded about what building a coalition of support for road pricing more generally.
Public transport travel times
Some bus passengers are going to benefit, a lot, from road pricing. It will reduce travel times, especially, but not only, on corridors without bus lanes and busways, because buses will be less caught in traffic. It will mean more services can operate with the same number of buses and drivers, but none of that is clear. Around half of people travelling to central Auckland already go by public transport, cycling or walking, but there is little in any of this to reach those people to tell them, this is about you as well.
There IS material about what improvements to public transport might accompany each option, but that is hidden in supplementary material that I suspect most won't read (do read it!). I know there is a balance to be struck between giving detail that might not happen, vs. giving better than a general idea about improvements, but this needed more detail.
It should be possible for Aucklanders to go online and click where they live and have an illustration of what public transport service improvements could come to within a reasonable distance of their home, and also what travel time savings they would experience going to other destinations. It would be about replicating a trip time calculator, which is expensive - but would be worth it if people could find out for themselves what pricing could do for them, whether they drive or ride.
Shoulders and operating times
The charge rates haven't been fixed yet, so ranges have been proposed. Most people will expect the highest will be implemented, but there is a factor which is barely visible at all, which is that charges will not be a single rate at peaks, but may step up and down from a peak rate with shoulder periods. This could mean people paying less at the beginning and end of the peaks. I know modellers don't like it, because it is difficult to factor in, but it is exactly the sort of detail that helps people understand how pricing works and how it can be designed to minimise negative impacts on those who have some flexibility. It is, after all, exactly how pricing works in Singapore, and to a lesser extent, Stockholm.
 |
| Singapore shoulder pricing at one charge point |
 |
| Stockholm AM peak shoulder charges |
Caps
There is no explicit talk about a daily cap in charges, although the likelihood is most drivers would only pay once in each direction. Uber and delivery drivers may pay several times if making multiple peak trips, but then is that really a problem? Incentivising travel off-peak is a big part of this charge, to get better use of the existing road network. Caps exist in other schemes because they operate all day (London, Stockholm, Gothenburg, Milan), Singapore has no cap because it only operates at specific times on some routes.
Use of net revenues
This is where there really should be maximum flexibility about what people want. While Auckland Council wants most net revenues to be spent on public transport, the public should be able to say if they want more spent on roads, or to use the revenues to offset rates for properties in certain areas, or to reduce other charges or even give people a "dividend" of the net revenues.
The last idea has been
proposed by Dr Eric Crampton from the New Zealand Initiative, and I think it
could make a huge difference to public acceptability. It won't be popular with the
Greater Auckland blog, because urbanists want more money for public transport. It won't be popular with road transport operators, because they will want more money for some new roads. However, I bet it would be popular with Aucklanders. Even if
half the money raised from Option C went on a congestion dividend, imagine the difference in public perception of road pricing.
If Auckland Councillors actually want to improve the productivity and efficiency of the city AND want to improve the environmental conditions, they could support time of use road pricing with a congestion dividend to get it over the line.
Sure there would be the obvious question as to who should receive it. Crampton suggests it go back to drivers, but it could also go to households within locations directly affected by the charge (note that is not the same as people living within a cordon). It certainly needs some work to refine, but it could be a game changer.
Politics
It would be nice if some central government politicians were supportive of the proposals.Auckland Central MP, Chlöe Swarbrick, from the Green Party (who was just re-elected) ought to be supportive, but as a party co-leader is more focused on the chance her party might be part of a change in government and gain extra MPs with the final results. However, adjacent MP, David Seymour from the ACT Party (who was also re-elected and arguably on the opposite end of the spectrum to the Greens), ought to be supportive as well. His electorate will be affected by all of the options, and as a classical liberal advocate for free market economics, he should support the idea depending on what is done with net revenues. He ought to be out there communicating to his constituents. The other two electorates nearby are Mt Albert (Labour) and Tamaki (National), with both those parties supporting the legislation for time of use charging as well. Both their MPs should be seeking to advocate for constituents and communicating to them, although the Tamaki MP elect is a new MP, he probably has a lot more to do in the coming weeks than advocating for road pricing!
Auckland Councillors have a range of views with a few already campaigning against any option, on the basis that it imposes an unfair burden on drivers. None of those councillors have any constructive alternatives, but generally think that the cost of the fee to drivers is not worth what benefit the drivers get in better travel times and travel time reliability. The Mayor is a strong advocate and helps a great deal, but he will need to be able to communicate to sceptics and opponents effectively.
My view - the options
Option C should proceed, with some flexibility about various elements of it. It should have the Option A cordon, which is tightly defined and easily understood. Care should be taken to model what routes would be slower under Option C, and to take steps to avoid this. Rat running can be fixed by having ANPR charging points on parallel routes based on vehicles passing two points to be charged. This has been proven to work in Sweden in two cases, so should be replicated in Auckland to deter diversion. Options to expand beyond Option C, with one or two charging points to mitigate significant increases in travel time, should be developed.
Consider staging Option C, so the cordon is launched first and issues with it ironed out, before launching the corridors.
Be willing to consider flexibility around prices more generally, by route and shoulder times. This is a far more complex scheme than Auckland, Stockholm, Milan or Abu Dhabi (but not Singapore), so you don't want to get it wrong.
Finally, it would be helpful when referencing Singapore to note that it reviews charges several times a year and may increase or decrease them according to traffic conditions at specific points. This should be replicated in some form. It should mean charges do not go up according to inflation, but will go up or done depending on demand. If too successful, charges should drop, or the operating hours constrained. This will help generate confidence that pricing will be about reducing congestion, not raising revenue.
Option A is hardly worth doing. It affects very few trips and will be (incorrectly) perceived as more negative on the city centre than positive given its impacts are so insignificant. It reflects a philosophy that pricing is only about drawing lines around areas as destinations than on pricing corridors that have demand beyond capacity. It simply doesn’t generate enough trips to make a difference. At best, it is a first stage to be followed by the rest of Option C, but on its own it is a demonstration of not very much at all.
Option B is Option A with more pain and insufficient gain. It will generate calls for residents’ discounts, for discounts/exemptions for the hospital at peak times, and the extra benefits are not worth this. Auckland’s congestion is not going to be eased sufficiently by a bigger cordon. It should not proceed.
Option C is a much better option because it charges corridors, and including Option A mitigates the risk of rat-running off the motorways onto parallel routes. It is a good, enough, start to managing congestion, especially on the Southern motorway, but it will not be enough, and should be seen as not an end point, but a start. It is big enough that its benefits should be clear throughout the Isthmus, and to some extent beyond.
My view - the consultation
It's very very easy for those deeply involved in road pricing projects to know and feel they know that what they are doing is justified and "if only people knew", they would support it. Urbanists and many on the Green left embrace it because they are supportive of most measures that penalise driving, but that view is not a majority one and will actively get the proposal killed. These are not the people who will necessarily convince a majority of people that this idea should be tried. Business people, those working in transport and logistics should embrace it because it will save them money, and make their businesses more productive, but again they are only a minority. What really matters is not frightening enough Aucklanders to oppose it.
The idea that paying for something that, on the face of it seems free now, will make it better for you, is alien to most people. Time of use charging is novel to most people, and they are not exactly encouraged to support it by looking at other cities that have it. No one is going to say Singapore, Stockholm or London are comparable to Auckland, let alone New York.
My great fear is that the consultation might just miss the mark, although it is somewhat under the radar given uncertainty about the general election final outcome.
Strategically, I think the message should be this:
- Congestion is a big problem, and building new roads and new public transport infrastructure isn't going to make a significant difference to this across the network.
- No growing city of Auckland’s size has sustainably reduced congestion by building capacity to meet that demand, either on roads or public transport in any case.
- It's not like Auckland hasn't had spending on its transport infrastructure, Tens of NZ$billions have been spent over 30 years upgrading roads (e.g. Western Ring Route) and public transport (rail electrification, City Rail Link, Northern and Eastern Busways), and more is planned, but it won't be enough.
- Only a 1.6% reduction in car trips in the peaks can make a big difference to making traffic flow more easily and reliably.
- Pricing can encourage that percentage to change mode or time of travel, saving time for those who still pay. A third of those who won't pay will also save time.
- It is NOT designed to raise money, but we want to know what you want the money to be spent on – roads, public transport or cutting other charges.
- We want feedback on the plans, where charges might be, how much they are, when they operate, what is done with the money.
Maybe it will be, if a preferred scheme is selected and proceeds to final consultation.
I’ve been working the road pricing space for over 25 years. I lived in London for 12 years, both within the charging zone and in the outer suburbs, and I paid the charge a couple of times. I’ve seen Stockholm’s scheme work, and evolve, and Singapore’s. I worked on Manchester’s high profile attempt to get a scheme approved from 2006 until 2008, only to watch it collapse due to a disastrous public consultation programme, combined with shockingly poor timing which saw public opposition swell. I’ve worked on Hong Kong’s second attempt to advance, only for that to collapse due to lobbying pressure, and I worked on the Congestion Question in Auckland from 2017-2019, which learned a lot from the successes and failures elsewhere. I advised New York on several details of its scheme a few years ago.
By and large, modellers get most of it right. Technically none of this is difficult or cutting edge (although questions are worth raising about NZTA’s tolling system given recent developments). The main risks around this project come from two sources:
- Transport planners
- Communicators
If the planners can't produce a design that actually benefits most people paying, it will fail. At the moment, it looks like they have done a reasonable job so far.
However, if the communicators can't reach the sceptics and the resistant, and especially those who are not very trusting of Council and transport planners (with some good reason - being that so many planners are actively antagonistic of drivers), then this will fail.
There is enormous potential to make what might be the biggest leap forward in Auckland's transport network productivity and efficiency in many years. It could be as dramatic as the Waterview Tunnel opening, but far more sustainable (and scaleable) in its impacts.
There are three points at which this project could be cancelled following this consultation. Momentum shouldn't be lost, and it's critical that no mistakes are made in getting this over all of the lines ahead, but I'm optimistic.
No comments:
Post a Comment